(SOPA Images / Getty Images)

Liberty Mutual is more than 100 years old, with origins dating to 1912, when it was formed in response to a state law requiring employers to provide workers’ compensation insurance to its employees. Massachusetts Employees’ Insurance Association, as it was then known, began as a mutual company, meaning that it was owned by its customers rather than stockholders. The company’s first auto insurance policy was issued at its first branch office in Springfield, Massachusetts, in 1914. It became Liberty Mutual Insurance Company in 1917.

Liberty Mutual started advertising in 1919, and in 1930, the company got even more visibility by providing safety literature for high school driving courses, which the company says was a precursor to its current-day teen driving safety program. In 1936, the company opened a new home office in Boston, and in 1937, it was operating in 48 states. In the early 1950s, the Liberty Mutual Research Institute paired up with the Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory to develop safer cars. This partnership resulted in some innovations that are still in use in new cars today.

Get Free Insurance Quotes

Get great auto insurance coverage at an even better price.

Liberty Mutual Is the 9th Best Car Insurance Company

Rank Company
1 USAA
2 Travelers
3 State Farm
4 GEICO
5 Farmers
6 Nationwide
7 Progressive
8 Allstate
9 Liberty Mutual
10 American Family

 

How We Created This Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Review

This car insurance review is based on a U.S. News & World Report survey of 2,799 consumers who filed a car insurance claim in the last five years. Respondents provided this data based on their experience with their car insurance company.

U.S. News also worked with Quadrant Information Services to provide a report of average insurance rates in all 50 states from the 10 largest national car insurance companies. The rates are based on profiles for both male and female drivers aged 17, 25, 35, and 60. Vehicles used include the 2018 Honda Civic, 2018 Toyota RAV4, 2018 Ford F-150, 2015 Honda Civic, 2015 Toyota RAV4, and 2015 Ford F-150, with annual mileage of 6,000 and 12,000. Three car insurance coverage levels were used, as were credit tiers of good, fair, and poor. Clean driving records and records with one accident, one speeding violation, and one DUI were also used in the calculations. The rates shown here are for comparative purposes only. Individual rates will differ.

Liberty Mutual Rating and Review

See the Best Car Insurance Companies

Liberty Mutual ranks nine out of 10 in our survey, ahead of only American Family.

Survey respondents were most satisfied with Liberty Mutual for how easy it was to file a claim, with just over 55 percent saying they were completely satisfied. After making the claim, however, customers said the process broke down. Several respondents said that it was hard to get an agent on the phone, agents didn't return calls or messages, and the claims process simply took too long. Other customers mentioned that Liberty Mutual was not aggressive enough about pursuing other insurance companies for settlements.

One respondent summed it up by saying, “Very poor claim handling process, very robotic, not customer focused.”

More than 53 percent of customers reported being completely satisfied with the customer service from Liberty Mutual. However, on every other attribute we measured, at least 50 percent of respondents reported being less than totally satisfied. Nearly 20 percent of respondents were dissatisfied with communication about claim status, and just over 20 percent were dissatisfied with how claims were resolved. That dissatisfaction showed when we asked how likely people were to recommend Liberty Mutual or renew their policy.

Nearly 30 percent of respondents reported that they were unlikely or very unlikely to recommend Liberty Mutual to someone shopping for car insurance, and just over 26 percent said they are either unlikely or very unlikely to renew their insurance with Liberty Mutual. As you can see from the responses below, several of the survey respondents have already switched away from Liberty Mutual. Others are staying with them, but reluctantly.

“My premiums increased far too much over the last four years,” said one respondent. Another decided to leave the insurer, saying, “They were going to raise my premiums a significant amount. So we switched to State Farm.”

“Expensive premiums. Already went switched to another company,” said one unhappy customer. “I switched to Allstate," said another. "They were the insurance company of the driver that ran the red light. And they were awesome!”

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Costs

See the Cheapest Car Insurance Companies

Liberty Mutual’s national average rate is $6,073. That's the most expensive average among all 10 companies in our survey – by a lot. The next most expensive company is Allstate, with an average rate of $4,888. The average Liberty Mutual customer could save almost $1,200 by switching to Allstate. Travelers comes in just ahead of Allstate, with a rate of $4,435. Farmers, Nationwide, American Family, State Farm, and USAA all offer substantial savings over Liberty Mutual.

Company Average Rate
USAA $2,537.30
Geico $3,215.01
State Farm $3,260.00
American Family $3,443.09
Nationwide $3,450.00
Progressive $4,035.52
Farmers $4,194.27
Travelers $4,434.91
Allstate $4,887.95
Liberty Mutual $6,073.45

When broken down by age, gender, and marital status, single 17-year-old females and males pay the highest rates of all Liberty Mutual customers. That's not a surprise, as most insurance companies charge more for young and inexperienced drivers because they are more likely to be in an accident. Seventeen-year-old males can expect to pay $13,719 and 17-year-old females can expect to pay $11,621. Liberty Mutual's rates decrease as customers get older and are consistently less expensive for women. Single 25-year-old females pay average rates of $3,960, while males pay $4,503. Married 35-year-old women pay an average of $3,803 with Liberty Mutual, and married 35-year-old men pay $3,857. For married 60-year-olds, women pay an average of $3,445 and men pay $3,681.

Group Average Rate
Single 17-year old female $11,621.01
Single 17-year old male $13,718.69
Single 25-year old female $3,959.67
Single 25-year old male $4,503.13
Married 35-year old female $3,802.77
Married 35-year old male $3,856.84
Married 60-year old female $3,445.00
Married 60-year old male $3,680.53

We looked at rates for customers who drive 6,000 miles per year and those who drive 12,000 miles per year. Liberty Mutual customers in the former group pay a little less, but the difference isn’t too bad. Those who drive less pay an average of $5,995, and those who drive more pay an average of $6,152.

Drivers who choose low coverage will pay about $5,806 with Liberty Mutual. The average rate goes up to $6,059 for medium coverage and $6,356 for high coverage.

Coverage Type Average Rate
Low $5,805.75
Medium $6,058.57
High $6,356.04

It’s a huge advantage to have a good credit score if you are a Liberty Mutual customer; these customers pay roughly half as much as those with poor credit. Top-tier credit gets Liberty Mutual customers average rates of $4,388. Customers with fair credit pay an average of $5,604, and customers with poor credit pay an average of $8,802.

Credit History Average Rate
Good $4,388.18
Fair $5,604.24
Poor $8,802.22

Not surprisingly, drivers with a clean record pay lower rates than those with accidents or tickets on their record. If you have a clean driving record, expect to pay around $4,774 with Liberty Mutual. A single speeding violation causes the average rate to jump to $5,701, a single accident bumps it to $6,205, and a DUI violation raises premiums to an average of $7,613.

Driving Record Average Rate
Clean record $4,774.30
With 1 speeding violation $5,701.26
With 1 accident $6,204.78
With 1 DUI $7,613.48

Who Should Get Liberty Mutual Car Insurance?

Strictly speaking, Liberty Mutual probably isn’t the best option for anyone, but if you fall into favored customer groups, you won’t do too bad. That is, Liberty Mutual may be a good option if you’re older, married, and have a history of good credit and responsible driving. Customers with higher risk factors, such as teenagers or those with poor driving records, should consider other companies. These customers will pay higher than average rates no matter what, but many other major insurance companies won’t charge as much as Liberty Mutual.

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance vs. Geico Auto Insurance

Geico takes the fourth spot in our rankings of major insurance companies and outscores Liberty Mutual by a healthy margin on every survey question.

With a national average rate of $3,215, Geico is much less expensive than Liberty Mutual, which charges an average of $6,073. Geico also charges lower average rates for single 17- and 25-year-old females and males and married 35- and 60-year-old females and males. The smallest difference is with married 60-year-old females, who will pay about $1,200 more with Liberty Mutual. The largest difference is with single 17-year-old males, who will pay about $7,500 more with Liberty Mutual, or more than twice Geico’s average rate of $6,279.

Whether you are looking at how much you drive, the amount of coverage you need, your credit history, or your driving record, Geico’s rates are considerably lower than Liberty Mutual’s. For example, Liberty Mutual’s rates for customers who drive 6,000 miles annually and those who drive 12,000 miles annually are both nearly twice as high as Geico’s. Geico also has some of the lowest rates for customers with one speeding violation or one accident, though rates are above average for drivers with one DUI. Liberty Mutual’s rates in these categories are the highest among all 10 companies in our survey.

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance vs. State Farm Auto Insurance

State Farm is our third-ranked auto insurance company, and its $3,260 average rate is among the lowest in the study. Only Geico and USAA are less expensive. Furthermore, State Farm’s average rates for the various demographics are considerably cheaper than Liberty Mutual’s. The difference between the two companies’ rates for single 25-year-old females is about $1,600, and it’s considerably higher in every other case.

Regardless of annual mileage driven, level of coverage, credit history, or driving record, State Farm customers will pay less than Liberty Mutual customers. Again, the differences are often a thousand dollars or more. State Farm customers also report higher satisfaction than Liberty Mutual’s.

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance vs. Allstate Auto Insurance

Liberty Mutual’s average rate of $6,073 is much higher than eighth-place Allstate’s national average rate of $4,888. Liberty Mutual is also more expensive for every age group regardless of gender. The smallest difference between the two, about $500, is for the married 60-year-old female category. Most of the differences are about a thousand dollars or more. Teenagers, for example, will pay upward of $2,000 more with Liberty Mutual.

Liberty Mutual’s premiums are consistently higher across the other factors that influence rates as well. Allstate customers who drive 6,000 miles per year will pay an average of $4,842, or about $1,150 less than Liberty Mutual customers. For those who drive 12,000 miles per year, Allstate increases rates by less than $100, but Liberty Mutual increases rates by just over $150, making Liberty Mutual’s rates the highest in the study for this category. Looking at coverage type, Liberty Mutual’s rates were higher than Allstate’s by almost $1,200 for low coverage, about $1,050 for medium coverage, and more than $1,200 for high coverage. Whether you have good, fair, or poor credit history, you’ll pay more with Liberty Mutual. In the case of poor credit history, the difference is about $2,300. Liberty Mutual customers also pay more regardless of driving record. In fact, Liberty Mutual’s rate for drivers with a clean record, $4,774, is higher than most competitors’ rates for a driver with a DUI.

Types of Coverage From Liberty Mutual Car Insurance

Let’s look at some of the different coverage types available from Liberty Mutual. Note that not all these coverage options are available in all states, and if you have a lease or a loan on your car, the finance company may require specific types of coverage.

Liberty Mutual’s standard car insurance policy includes bodily injury liability and property damage, which cover any injuries or damage as a result of an accident you cause. The standard coverage also includes medical payments, which kick in if you or your passengers are injured in an accident. Liberty Mutual backs these standard features with 24-hour customer service, a 12-month rate guarantee, and a lifetime repair guarantee.

Get Free Car Insurance Quotes

Get great auto insurance coverage at an even better price.


Additional coverage options include collision, which covers repairs to your car after a collision, and comprehensive, which covers damage to your car from something other than a collision.

Several add-on options are available. Enrolling in the Liberty Mutual Deductible Fund will help you reduce or eliminate your deductible. Accident Forgiveness coverage will keep your rates from going up after your first accident. The Lifetime Repair Guarantee coverage means that Liberty Mutual will back your car’s repairs as long as they were performed by an approved repair facility. You can opt to ensure that your new car is replaced with another new car or a car that is a model year newer. Rental Car Reimbursement coverage ensures that you’ll have a car to drive while yours is being repaired.

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Complaints

Complaints from current and former Liberty Mutual customers tend to focus on cost, communication and customer service during the claims process, and the claims process itself. The quotes below were provided by survey respondents to clarify their responses to the survey questions or provide additional information. Some participants in the study noted that they have since switched from Liberty Mutual to a rival company.

“Expensive and reluctant to pay a claim.”

“My premiums increased far too much over the last four years.”

“[A] Liberty Mutual insured [customer] ran into the back of our car. Service and handling of our claim has been poor. Accident occurred November 2017 and still remains unresolved.”

“I had to replace a windshield chipped by a stone. They raised my rates significantly. I took my business elsewhere. I get a laugh when I watch their ad on TV for ‘accident forgiveness.’”

“I was in an accident June 27th. My car was totaled, the fault was not mine. I was very disappointed with the follow through to go after the other insurance company. I left a message for my agent and he did not call me back.”

“We had a long wait for our car to be repaired, which was brought on by the insurance company.”

“Accident not my fault and instead of telling me to file my claim with the other person's insurance company, they went ahead and filed it telling me they'd get back repayment from the other insurance company. Six months later, I'm out my $500 deductible and the case is closed because the other insurance company didn't pay. Terrible service and because of that, I switched to Geico.”

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Discounts

One of the most common ways to save money on a car insurance policy is through bundling, also known as a multipolicy discount. Like most companies, Liberty Mutual offers car insurance discounts to customers who bundle a home (or condo or renters) policy with auto insurance. Liberty Mutual also offers certain billing discounts. For example, you could save by opting in to automatic billing or by paying your premium in full instead of in installments. You can also save money with a multi-car discount. If your household has more than one vehicle, consider putting them all on the same policy to save some money.

Some cars will qualify for specific discounts based on the type of car or any special equipment that is installed. Hybrid cars qualify for an alternative energy discount, and cars with safety features such as anti-lock brakes, electronic stability control, adaptive headlights, rearview cameras, and anti-theft devices qualify for a vehicle safety features discount. Ask your insurance agent if there are any additional features that will qualify your car for one of these discounts.

Students under the age of 26 who maintain a B average or better qualify for a good student discount. And, if you have recently moved, you may get a discount with Liberty Mutual just for updating the address on your policy.

Other Types of Policies From Liberty Mutual

Though Liberty Mutual got its start as an auto insurance company, it has expanded considerably over the last hundred years. Liberty Mutual’s available policies and products extend to other types of vehicles, as well as other types of insurance.

If you have a motorcycle, Liberty Mutual’s coverage options include better bike replacement, new bike replacement, and coverage for accessories or upgrades installed on the bike. Discounts for safety training and experienced riders are available too. Liberty Mutual also provides customized insurance policies for boats, yachts, and jet skis, with discounts available for safety training and experience.

Whether you own a home, own a condo, or rent, Liberty Mutual offers coverage suitable for your needs. Homeowners insurance policies cover your dwelling, personal possessions, liability, and additional living expenses related to a disaster that forces you to leave your home. Condo insurance covers your possessions inside the unit, liability, and common areas of the condo development. Renters can get a policy that covers personal property, liability, and additional living expenses and medical payments related to accidents on the property. Additional coverage can be added for expensive personal items like jewelry and computers.

For extra coverage, consider a personal umbrella insurance policy. An umbrella policy provides extra liability coverage in case of an auto accident or an incident in your home or on your property. A single umbrella insurance policy extends to all your other policies with Liberty Mutual and provides extra coverage if an incident exhausts your liability limits with your other policies. This policy must be bundled with an auto insurance policy with a minimum liability limit.

Although Liberty Mutual is planning to consolidate its life insurance business (see the next section for more details), as of this writing, term life insurance and permanent life insurance products are still offered on Liberty Mutual’s website, along with annuities.

Liberty Mutual Financial Fitness

Liberty Mutual had a couple of rough quarters in 2017 and 2018, due to unprecedented payouts as a result of natural disasters. In January of 2018, Liberty Mutual announced plans to sell off its life insurance division and restructure its consumer and commercial insurance businesses. The company’s earnings report for the second quarter of 2018, which was published in August 2018, cited net income of $981 million over the three-month period ending June 30, and net income of $1.629 billion for the six-month period ending June 30. However, net losses for the three-month period were $59 million, as compared to the $18 million lost in the same period for 2017.

As of June 30, 2018, Liberty Mutual had total equity of $20.880 billion, an increase of $192 million over the previous six-month period. Total debt was $8.271 billion, down $54 million from the previous six-month period.

Liberty Mutual is taking steps to get back on track following recent loses. Customers and potential customers should not be concerned about Liberty Mutual’s ability to pay out claims.

Other Insurance Brands Related to Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual has several subsidiaries. Under the Liberty Mutual Group umbrella, the main corporate structure includes Liberty Mutual Holding Company Inc., LMHC Massachusetts Holding Inc., and Liberty Mutual Group Inc., which is then split into the following entities: Liberty Corporate Services LLC, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company, and Employers Insurance Company of Wausau.

Other affiliated companies include Safeco, Ironshore, Liberty Mutual Group Asset Management, Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance, Liberty General Insurance, Liberty International Underwriters, Ohio Casualty, Helmsman Management Services, Liberty Citystate Holdings Pte Ltd, St. James Insurance Company Ltd., and Wausau Insurance.

Contact Liberty Mutual

You can contact Liberty Mutual at www.libertymutual.com/customer-service/contact-us. The company can be emailed through their web portal, tweeted at @AskLiberty, or reached by telephone. The customer service number is 1-800-290-8711. For claims, use 1-800-225-2467. For 24-hour roadside assistance, call 1-800-426-9898.

Get Free Insurance Quotes

Get great auto insurance coverage at an even better price.